It all ended over twenty years ago, but they never forgot each other or the love they’d shared. High school sweethearts are brought back together by the daughter they’d decided would be better off without them in this second chance, small town romance.

After Becca and her high school boyfriend, Finn, made an adoption plan, Becca was heartbroken. The day their biological daughter was born, Becca told Finn to stay out of her life. But that was decades ago, and not what she’d truly wanted.

She’s lived with regret even though it was clear she and Finn weren’t ready to become parents at eighteen. But Becca knew keeping Finn in her life would be a constant reminder of the child she’d wanted to keep. So she ended their relationship and tried her best to move on with her life.

Even after marrying another man, she never stopped loving Finn.

Finn has been trying to let time heal his wounds, but losing Becca shattered him. He’s never been able to fully move on or love another woman. But he respected Becca’s wish to stay out of her life the day their daughter was born.

Now their daughter, Molly, wants to know her biological parents. In order to have the best relationship he can with his daughter, Finn wants to make things right with Becca. But can Becca forgive him for not fighting for her?

They’ve both spent years trying to forget each other and move on. Will Molly bring them back together? Or will she help them see they were never meant to be?

Deep wounds, regret, and a second chance for a family, this contemporary second chance romance will scratch your What-If itch.