A house you haven’t even bought yet starts chasing you in your dreams and then you walk through the front door and the staircase is the same. That’s where Cindy Sarro’s Caseyville, Illinois nightmare begins, and we follow the trail all the way to the thing she swears lived behind one ordinary wall. We’re Josh, Jamie, and Elisa, and we dig into Cindy’s account from her book The Wall with the details that make this story hit so hard: the girls who refuse their bedroom, the lights that won’t behave, the TV that turns itself on, and the sense of being watched night after night from the same spot.

As the haunting escalates, Cindy describes involuntary astral projection followed by invisible beatings, plus apparitions that seem to “try on” different faces: a little boy from another time, a soldier-like man filled with hatred, and an old woman staring back from the mirror. Then comes the moment that still creeps us out to say out loud: a pink smoke cloud pouring from the wall, pulling at the home’s electricity, and moving toward the room where her kids sleep. We also talk through the non-paranormal angles that can’t be ignored in any serious haunted house discussion, including faulty wiring, chronic pain, intense stress, and what sleep deprivation can do to the mind and body.

And the danger isn’t only supernatural. Glenn’s behavior turns frightening, culminating in an axe at the door, and Cindy’s attempts to get help bring their own frustration: churches that back away, a priest who questions her sanity, a cleansing that seems to do nothing, and a final decision to sell and escape. If you’re into paranormal stories, demonic haunting lore, and the messy intersection of fear and family life, this one is a ride. Subscribe for more, share this with a friend who loves haunted house cases, and leave a review with your take: was it a demonic entity, a perfect storm of stress and wiring, or something tied to the land?

Thank you for listening to the Paranormal Peeps Podcast. Check us out on Facebook Paranormal Peeps Podcast or Coldspot Paranormal Research and on Instagram coldspot_paranormal_research

Support the show

A cemetery that invites you to pack a picnic sounds impossible until you meet Victorian London. We’re heading to Highgate Cemetery, where a public health crisis and a radical new “garden cemetery” idea turned burial grounds into landscaped parks and then, decades later, into the kind of overgrown Gothic maze that practically writes ghost stories for you. We walk through the design choices that make Highgate feel like a built-in underworld, from the sunken Egyptian Avenue to the shadowed Circle of Lebanon and the hillside layout that keeps Victorian class divisions alive even in death.

From there we get into the rituals that shaped the era’s relationship with grief. We talk strict mourning phases, the heavy black veils, and the unsettling fact that some mourning fabrics were treated with chemicals that could harm the people wearing them. We dig into memento mori traditions like hair jewelry and post-mortem photography, plus the superstitions that still raise goosebumps: mirrors covered, clocks stopped, bodies carried out feet first, and tomb symbols that speak in code. If you’re into Victorian history, cemetery architecture, and death culture, this is the deep end.

Then the haunt reports begin. We compare recurring Highgate sightings: a towering shadow entity tied to cold drops and sudden silence, the “Mad Mother” tearing through the West Cemetery, a Swain’s Lane encounter where something manifests from brickwork and shoves a man flat, and a red-eyed figure at the gates that leaves a driver frozen in place. We also explore the melancholic nun that seems to bend distance itself, and the most beautiful story of all: a concert pianist’s grave where witnesses say sorrowful music rises from beneath the stone grand piano.

Subscribe for more paranormal history, share this with a friend who loves haunted places, and leave us a review with your theory: are these imprints, entities, or something stranger?

Thank you for listening to the Paranormal Peeps Podcast. Check us out on Facebook Paranormal Peeps Podcast or Coldspot Paranormal Research and on Instagram coldspot_paranormal_research

Support the show

A quiet mansion on 18 acres. An indoor pool in the basement. A string of men who vanish after nights out in Indianapolis. Fox Hollow Farm isn’t just a haunted location people whisper about, it’s the center of a case that still makes your stomach drop once you see how long it took the pieces to connect.

We walk through the rise of Herbert R. Baumeister from an outwardly successful husband, father, and business owner to a suspected serial killer tied to disappearances from downtown gay bars in the late 80s and early 90s. We also unpack the survivor story that helped break the case open, the investigation’s dead ends, and the moment police finally gain access to the property only to uncover thousands of human bones and fragments scattered through woods and a creek bed. Along the way, we talk about the brutal reality of early DNA testing costs and how hard it was for families to get answers.

Then we shift into the paranormal side that gives Fox Hollow Farm its second reputation. We cover reports from later owners and investigators, why the basement pool and pump room keep coming up, and the theories we hear again and again: residual trauma, a portal connected to water, and the unsettling idea of something darker that mimics Baumeister for its own gain. We also share why we appreciate a grounded approach like Richard Estep’s The Horrors of Fox Hollow Farm, where debunking matters and “nothing happened” is still part of the truth.

Subscribe for more true crime and paranormal history, share this with a friend who loves the dark corners of both worlds, and leave a review with your take: do you think Fox Hollow Farm is haunted by victims, a mimic, or something else entirely?

Thank you for listening to the Paranormal Peeps Podcast. Check us out on Facebook Paranormal Peeps Podcast or Coldspot Paranormal Research and on Instagram coldspot_paranormal_research

Support the show