In this episode of True Crime Time, Woody Overton takes listeners through a series of crimes connected by a single date — Valentine’s Day. While the holiday is often marketed as a celebration of love, its history is marked by some of the most notorious crimes on record.

The episode begins with a discussion of the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre, a pivotal moment in American organized crime that reshaped public awareness of gang violence. Woody explains why this event still matters today and how it set the tone for future criminal history tied to the holiday.

From there, the focus shifts to high-profile Valentine’s Day murders, including the widely publicized case of Oscar Pistorius, whose trial captivated the world and raised complex questions about justice, celebrity, and accountability.

Woody also covers recent violent incidents in Louisiana, showing that Valentine’s Day crimes are not limited to history books. Several cases discussed remain unsolved, reinforcing the importance of continued investigation, public awareness, and community involvement.

The episode closes with reflections on the origins of Valentine’s Day, the pattern of violence associated with the date, and why pursuing justice — regardless of the calendar — remains essential for victims and their families.

00:00 Valentine’s Day and Crime

02:08 The St. Valentine’s Day Massacre

06:31 High-Profile Valentine’s Day Murders

10:52 Valentine’s Day Crimes in Louisiana

14:50 Historical Crimes on February 14

17:40 The Origins of Valentine’s Day

20:05 Justice, Cold Cases, and Accountability

Valentine’s Day true crime, St. Valentine’s Day Massacre, Oscar Pistorius murder, Valentine’s Day murders, Louisiana Valentine’s Day crime, unsolved Valentine’s Day cases, historical true crime, cold case investigations, justice for victims, true crime podcast

This Valentine’s Day episode of True Crime Time explores historic and modern crimes tied to February 14, including the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre, high-profile murders, and unsolved cases that continue to demand justice.

Executive Producer: Leah Marie